EIGHTY MINUTES Match index The blog

Entropy in Black: Why the All Blacks Forgot How to Play Rugby

Wales beat the All Blacks 35-28 in Cardiff. My argument is that New Zealand rugby is suffering from entropy.

·

Result
Wales 35–28 New Zealand
Competition
Nations Championship 2026, Round 5
Venue
Principality Stadium, Cardiff
Date
Wales tries
Tomos Williams (2'), Dewi Lake (6'), Archie Griffin (24'), Eddie James (44'), Louis Rees-Zammit (49')
New Zealand tries
Cortez Ratima (10'), Wallace Sititi (31'), Fehi Fineanganofo (40+3'), Peter Lakai (53')

Cardiff, 14 November 2026

Wales beat the All Blacks 35-28 in Cardiff on Saturday, their first win over New Zealand since 1953 and the end of a 34-Test losing streak. Wales started the day ranked tenth, New Zealand second. Measured by the ranking-points gap, it was a bigger shock than Japan beating South Africa in 2015, and NBC called it the biggest upset in Test rugby since that day in Brighton.

The easy explanation is a bad night with a second-string side. Dave Rennie made ten changes. Tyrel Lomax, Samisoni Taukei'aho and Shannon Frizell were injured; Will Jordan, Cam Roigard, Ardie Savea and Jordie Barrett were not in the starting XV. New Zealand turned the ball over nine times in the first half, had three tries held up in the final half hour and started both halves slowly. Wales made 346 tackles to New Zealand's 134.

All true. But the easy explanation hides the interesting one. A team that rotates ten players and loses its set piece has not just had a bad night. It has shown what its system produces below the first XV.

My argument is that New Zealand rugby is suffering from entropy. A system cut off from outside energy slowly loses structure in the parts it stops feeding. Since South Africa left Super Rugby, New Zealand's domestic game has lost its main source of set-piece pressure. It keeps producing world-class runners and loose forwards and under-produces tight-five technicians. That deficit does not depend on whether the coach prefers to kick or run. It has shown up under both, and Saturday was the night it showed up against a team ranked tenth.

The season in numbers

The 2026 record is 7 wins and 4 losses: not a collapse, but a pattern. New Zealand beats sides that want an open game and loses to sides that squeeze it at the set piece.

DateOpponentVenueResultWhat decided it
14 NovWalesCardiffLost 28-35Ten changes, nine first-half turnovers, wayward lineout, quick taps instead of the maul
7 NovScotlandEdinburghWon 43-21Level at 24-21 at half-time, pulled away after
17 OctAustraliaSydneyWon 43-2136 first-half points
10 OctAustraliaAucklandWon 50-19Error-ridden first-half lineout, then Wallaby indiscipline opened the game up
12 SepSouth AfricaBaltimoreLost 28-43Boks outscored them six tries to four
5 SepSouth AfricaSowetoLost 24-29Bok scrum won 5-0 on penalties plus a penalty try
29 AugSouth AfricaCape TownLost 26-33Three attacking lineouts spoiled; first two Bok tries from mauls
22 AugSouth AfricaJohannesburgWon 33-16Won despite losing the scrum for 54 minutes
18 JulIrelandAucklandWon 40-2128-7 up at half-time
11 JulItalyWellingtonWon 47-17Italy down to 14 from the 51st minute
4 JulFranceChristchurchWon 34-32Survived a French side that kept kicking and contesting

The context makes the pattern sharper. In September 2025, under Scott Robertson, New Zealand lost 43-10 to South Africa in Wellington, their heaviest defeat ever, with the Boks dominating scrum and lineout. Two months later England beat them 33-19 at Twickenham. Robertson was sacked on 15 January 2026 after an internal review, and Rennie was appointed in March. The coach and the game plan changed. The set-piece deficit did not.

Entropy: it isn't the game plan

In systems thinking, entropy is the drift of a closed system toward disorder. Structure costs energy to maintain. The parts a system stops feeding decay quietly, until load arrives and they fail.

The tempting version of this story says the All Blacks are too proud of running rugby. The timeline doesn't support it. Robertson's 2025 side was territory-first and kick-heavy, and it suffered the worst defeats. Rennie switched styles: his 2026 side makes roughly 90 more carries and 100 more passes per game than Robertson's, and keeps the ball in play about five minutes longer. Running New Zealand has lost less badly than kicking New Zealand.

So the problem sits one level below the game plan. Whatever the coach asks for, the system keeps handing him the same raw material: outstanding backs and loose forwards, and a thin, inconsistent set piece. In the Nations Championship in July, New Zealand's lineout success was 83%, the worst in the tournament, against an average of 91% and South Africa's 94%. Across the first three Tests against the Springboks, the scrum penalty count was 12-1 to South Africa.

Cardiff made it visible. Hooker Asafo Aumua overthrew two lineouts in the first half; prop Fletcher Newell was penalised at the third scrum for pulling down the Welsh loosehead. Two of Wales' tries came from lineouts, one off a drive. The defining moment came late. With penalties close to the line, the on-field leaders, Beauden Barrett, Scott Barrett and Richie Mo'unga, took quick taps instead of kicking to the corner. Forwards coach Neil Barnes said the half-time message had been to use the lineout drive more, and that scrum coach Jason Ryan was shouting for the maul on the last chance. Barnes would have gone to the lineout himself.

But he also explained the hesitation: from five metres out, you risk not even winning your own lineout. That is entropy in a single decision. The leaders didn't trust their set piece, so they reached for the thing they trust, ball in hand, and ran into 346 Welsh tackles. Rennie's own verdict was that the attack got "a bit one-dimensional."

The closed loop: losing the scrummaging opponent

New Zealand never left SANZAAR. South Africa effectively did. After the 2020 season the South African franchises moved to the northern-hemisphere United Rugby Championship, and Super Rugby became Super Rugby Pacific: New Zealand and Australian sides, plus Fiji and Moana Pasifika. The New Zealand teams lost their weekly exposure to the Bulls, Stormers and Sharks, the opponents who brought South African scrummaging and maul pressure into every season.

This isn't just my theory. In September 2026 a member of the All Blacks coaching staff pointed to South Africa's exit from Super Rugby as a cause of New Zealand's scrum struggles. Rugby365 has described a prevailing Super Rugby attitude that set pieces are simply a way to restart the game. RugbyPass was making a similar "producing proper Test forwards" argument as early as 2022. That is what entropy looks like: not a sudden failure, but years of slow drift.

Two honest qualifications. First, "closed" alone isn't the variable. Ireland also picks almost entirely home-based players, and its set piece is strong, because its players face Leinster, Munster, Ulster, the Welsh regions and South African packs every month. The real variable is the diversity of pressure inside the system. Second, Super Rugby is not simply "running rugby": Nick Bishop's analysis for RugbyPass found it has less ball in play than the Premiership or URC. The issue is not tempo. It is how rarely a young New Zealand prop meets a pack that wants to beat him at the scrum.

South Africa went the other way. Its players now spend every season in that northern contest and bring the information home. New Zealand's players mostly meet each other and Australian sides with similar instincts. When inputs look like outputs, each season reinforces what the last one rewarded.

The Bledisloe echo chamber

Watching the 2026 Bledisloe Tests, I found them boring, which is a strange thing to say about 93 New Zealand points in two matches. Both sides were obsessed with keeping the ball alive. After Eden Park, Rugby.com.au noted that the All Blacks made it clear they wanted the ball in play. Australia's best moments in Sydney were early half-breaks from Max Jorgensen and Fraser McReight. Two teams were playing the same game, and the better version of it won.

The scores were 50-19 in Auckland and 43-21 in Sydney. New Zealand has now held the Bledisloe Cup for 24 consecutive years, and Australia hasn't beaten them since November 2020. The Wallabies' coach that night in Brisbane was Dave Rennie. Yet even in the 50-pointer, New Zealand's first-half lineout was error-ridden; it just didn't cost them against an opponent that wasn't set up to punish it.

That is the danger of a closed loop: it generates confidence, not information. Reuters wrote after the series that the hard lessons of South Africa seemed to have paid off. I'd read it the other way. A 50-19 win over a team that plays like you teaches you almost nothing about a team that won't.

Meeting other systems: the Springboks and Wales

A closed system is tested when it meets an open one. In 2026 that happened twice.

South Africa. The four-Test Greatest Rivalry series began with a 33-16 win at Ellis Park, five tries to one, ending a 12-Test Bok winning streak. But even that win carried a warning. New Zealand's scrum was beaten for 54 minutes, at 57% success, and only reached parity when the bench front row came on: Fletcher Newell and Asafo Aumua, the same pair who struggled in Cardiff. New Zealand won Ellis Park with 39% of territory, on finishing alone.

Then the Springboks adapted. In Cape Town, Eben Etzebeth spoiled three attacking New Zealand lineouts and stole one, and South Africa's first two tries came off lineout mauls. Cheslin Kolbe kicked his goals instead of going to the corner. New Zealand complained to World Rugby about the scrum refereeing; Rennie later conceded World Rugby didn't see it his way. In Soweto the Bok scrum won the penalty count 5-0 and earned a penalty try. Barnes said afterwards that New Zealand had to "eat humble pie." South Africa took the series 3-1 in Baltimore.

There is a counter-reading, and it deserves space. Nine of South Africa's 12 scrum penalties came on their own feed, and New Zealand's analyst rated its own-feed scrum as good. He put the losses down to contestable kicks, kick receipt and discipline as much as the set piece. Ardie Savea was lost early in Soweto and missed Baltimore. Still, a 12-1 penalty count is not a refereeing quirk. It is a pattern.

Wales. Cardiff was a smaller version of the same lesson. Wales didn't try to out-run New Zealand. They scored early, used the lineout to create two tries, defended relentlessly and let New Zealand's errors do the rest. Beauden Barrett said it felt like playing 16 or 17 men. When New Zealand needed a different tool to break that defence, the five-metre maul, its leaders didn't reach for it.

Talent leakage: the NRL at the school gate

The NRL isn't raiding the All Blacks. It is fishing in the pipeline that feeds them, which is slower and harder to see.

In 2024 the Warriors claimed an "unprecedented influx" of union players, with 36 signings from rugby schools who had no league background. Since then Parramatta, Newcastle and South Sydney have all signed young New Zealand union prospects, and NRL scouts now work New Zealand's schoolboy competitions.

The link to the All Blacks' set piece is a hypothesis, not a finding, and I want to be clear about that. League clubs hunt explosive, powerful athletes rather than halfbacks or first fives, and RugbyPass has argued New Zealand has a surplus of exactly that athlete. No one publishes data on which positions the NRL takes. But the athlete profile league wants overlaps with the big teenagers who might otherwise become props and locks. If that is true, it reinforces the drift from below: the system keeps its runners and loses some of its future tight five. It is a question worth NZR answering with data.

The eligibility wall

New Zealand is now the outlier among the big southern nations. South Africa picks from anywhere, and Rugby Australia scrapped its Giteau Law in August 2025 to do the same. New Zealand still requires All Blacks to be contracted in New Zealand, with sabbaticals as the main exception. NZR chief executive Steve Lancaster restated that policy in May 2026, arguing it keeps the best players at home and the domestic game strong.

The wall is more porous than its reputation. Ardie Savea (Kobe) and Rieko Ioane (Leinster) have played abroad on sabbaticals. Richie Mo'unga became eligible again by coming home to Canterbury and the Crusaders, and was called into the South Africa tour squad in August. On 29 October Lancaster opened the door to Test players turning out for Australian Super Rugby sides, though no rule has changed yet. Opinion inside the camp is split: Rennie wants Brodie Retallick back from Japan, Damian McKenzie wants the rule changed, and defence coach Tana Umaga has softened after watching South Africa's success. Beauden Barrett and Wayne Pivac back the policy.

The systems argument here is about information, not just talent. A Springbok forward who scrummages in the Top 14 or mauls for Leinster brings back knowledge of how the set piece is coached and refereed in a different ecosystem. Under New Zealand's rules, a player who gains that knowledge in his prime is normally outside the pool until he comes home. Dalton Papali'i, Akira Ioane and Hoskins Sotutu all left. Ireland shows that a home-based policy can work, but only when the home competition supplies the variety. New Zealand's doesn't, so its eligibility rule shuts the other window too.

The case against, and what an open system would look like

Any honest version of this argument has to answer four objections.

  1. Cardiff was a rotated side. Ten changes and three injured forwards. True, but depth is the point. A system's health shows in its second-choice tight five, and New Zealand's couldn't hold the lineout.
  2. The Bok series was lost in the air and on discipline, not just the scrum. Partly true; the analysts who say so are right that the kicking contest mattered. But the scrum penalty count was 12-1 and the lineout was the tournament's worst, so the set piece was at least part of the story.
  3. New Zealand did face South African packs in 2026. On tour they beat all four South African franchises, the Stormers, Bulls, Sharks and Lions. But four tour matches are not a season of it, and the Test scrum still lost the penalty count 12-1.
  4. The policy protects the domestic game. NZR's view is that opening selection would hollow out Super Rugby. That is a real trade-off, not mere stubbornness.

Even granting all four, the pattern holds across two coaches and two game plans: New Zealand wins against teams that play its game and struggles against teams that attack the set piece.

What would reopening the system look like?

  • Import scrummaging pressure. Push SANZAAR and the URC for regular cross-hemisphere club fixtures, A-team tours and front-row exchanges, so young props meet the packs that will test them.
  • Make the tight five an identity, not hygiene. Select, coach and celebrate set-piece work the way New Zealand celebrates its back three, from schools upwards.
  • A New Zealand Giteau Law. Let overseas-based players back above a cap or age threshold, so experience gained abroad comes home instead of being lost.
  • Measure the NRL leak. Track which positions the pipeline loses, and invest where league is hunting.

Entropy isn't a verdict; it's a direction of travel. Systems reverse it by letting energy in. Cardiff was the bill for a decade of keeping the doors shut.

Sources

Cardiff

2025-2026 results and coaching

Springbok series

Super Rugby and the system

Bledisloe

NRL and eligibility

Watch the match, moment by moment